Prophet Muhammad is innocent from the Hadiths

0109islamart01

Millions of Muslims all over the world have been brought up to believe that the collections of hadith by Bukhari and Moslim provide the authentic words and teachings of the prophet Muhammad. These two collections have been labelled “sahih” (authentic). The majority of these hadith portray a chain of narrators in a chinese whispers fashion attributing sayings to the Prophet (e.g. A said that B said that C said ……. that G said, that the Prophet said). Often the chain extends to seven names or even more, yet for some reason the hadith advocates still deemed these hadith to be the authentic and genuine sayings of the Prophet! With an extremely naive type of logic. It is assumed that every person in the chain, not only was totally honest, but that he had a super human memory to enable him to narrate accurately incidents that took place one hundred or two hundred years earlier.! How did they come to this conclusion?

The hadith advocates have devised a very simple criteria for the assessment of any hadith. To them, the validity of any hadith is dependant on the integrity of the narrator! They will tell us that hadith no 374 (for example) is a genuine hadith because the narrator has been checked for good character!

Bearing in mind that these narrators lived 14 centuries ago, we may enquire: Were they checked by contemporaries of their time, by hadith scholars today or who? Needless to say, the claim to endorse the integrity of 6 or 7 narrators who transmitted a story through a chinese whisper type of chain, and who all lived 14 centuries ago, and whom we have never seen or heard of (except from the hadith books themselves) is a very naive practice to say the least!

But that is not all, even if the integrity of each one in the chain is beyond question, what about the errors that occur merely through the effect of a chinese whisper chain?

For demonstration of this concept please refer to: Chinese Whispers

In view of the above, common sense implies that we should disregard this farcical process. This criteria should have been discarded a long time ago. It is totally unreliable and is simply unacceptable. It seems absurd that the obvious criteria (and actually the only reliable one), by which to test the authenticity of any hadith was ignored!

Since the authenticity of the Quran, being the un-corrupted word of God, is not a matter of dispute by any Muslim, then it would make better sense to assess the authenticity of any hadith by determining whether this hadith is in harmony with Quranic truth or whether in fact it is in violation of Quranic truth. Sadly, the hadith scholars are not interested whether any one hadith contradicts the Quran or not, for if such occasion arrises, they will quickly describe the Quranic verse (which contradicts the hadith) as beeing abrogated!
For details of this great lie against the Quran please check: The lie of Quranic Abrogation

All the time, the scholars should have been checking the content of the hadith itself rather than the farcical character reference of the narrators!

It must be stressed here that testing the authenticity of any hadith is not for the purpose of approving the hadith as a source of religious law. The reader of the Quran should be well aware that God sanctions the Quran to be the sole source of religious law:

“Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?” 6:114

Testing the authenticity of any hadith is only relevant for historic purposes and for the benefit of those who wish to research the life of the Prophet. After all, and as we shall see later, the Prophet himself prohibited his people from writing or documenting his hadith, which makes the whole collection of hadith books a very dubious matter indeed.

Consequently, and if we try to apply the only logical criteria for testing the hadith (its compliance with the Quran) we are immediately faced with serious contradictions between a large number of hadith on one hand and between the Quran on the other hand. However, if we accept that the Prophet of God would never have taught anything that violates or contradicts the Quran, then we must conclude that any hadith which contradicts the Quran, and which is attributed to the Prophet, is indeed a lie and a fabrication which the prophet is innocent of.

Our starting point is to examine the following two contradicting hadith.

In the first hadith it is reported that the Prophet said to his people shortly before his death:

“I have left you the Quran and my sunna”

Yet in another hadith the Prophet commands his people quite the opposite:

“Do not write down anything of me except the Quran. Whoever writes other than that should delete it” (Ahmed, Vol. 1, page 171…..also Sahih Muslim )

In accordance with accepting the Quran to be the best criteria to judge the authenticity of any hadith, let us look into these two hadith and proceed to determine which of the two is in harmony with the teachings of the Quran.

To do so, it is essential to refer to a number of Quranic verses:

1- The Quran confirms that the only sunna is the sunna of God. No where in the Quran is there any mention of a sunna for Muhammad!!!!

“You will find that the sunna of Allah is the only sunna” (33:62….35:43…..48:23)

2- The Quran commands all Muslims to follow the Quran Alone, this command is found in numerous verses, the following are examples:

“These are God’s revelations that We recite to you truthfully. In which hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?” 45:6

“Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?” 6:114

“This scripture (Quran) has been revealed to you – you shall not harbour doubt about it in your heart – that you may warn with it, and to provide a reminder for the believers. You shall all follow what is revealed to you from your Lord; do not follow any idols besides Him. Rarely do you take heed.” 7:2-3

The above Quranic verses confirm the following matters:

a– That the sunna of God is the only sunna.

b– That God commands us to follow the Quran as the only source of religious law.

As a result, we must conclude that in no way would the prophet of God have uttered words against the commands and words of God, neither would he have advocated to have a sunna of his own which the believers should follow.

Immediately, we must discard the hadith that says : “I have left you the Quran and my sunna

The Quranic words above prove conclusively that the prophet Muhammad could not have ever said such words. This hadith violates the Quran and must be regarded as a fabrication and a lie against the Prophet.

The Quranic words above also confirm that the second hadith may be regarded as authentic since it is in harmony with the words of the Quran.

In accordance with the instructions left by the Prophet as per the second hadith, we find that for the first 200 years after the death of the Prophet the writing of his hadith was prohibited. Historically, the absence of any documented hadith for two whole centuries also confirms that the Prophet never left his people with anything but the Quran, and that the second of the above hadith is the correct one.

We know that out of all the hadith collections regarded as “sahih” (authentic) today, the collection of Al-Bukhari was the first to be documented. But Al-Bukhari was born in the year 194 After Hijrah. For more details about the history of hadith please see the following pages:

True History of hadith 1
True History of hadith 2

The aim of this research is to demonstrate numerous examples of the very clear contradictions between various hadith that are described by the hadith scholars to be “sahih” (authentic) and between the Quran. This will hopefully demonstrate to the reader how the prophet Muhammad is totally innocent of the thousands of fabricated hadith that are falsely attributed to him.

Important Note: It has been the habit of the followers of hadith to try to discredit anyone who questions the authenticity of hadith. Immediately, they would accuse him of not accepting prophet Muhammad as God’s messenger, and other equally unfounded accusations! However, if it can be proved that these hadith which they call “sahih” contain an abundance of contradictions with the Quran, then this research in actual fact becomes a genuine defence of the integrity and purity of the prophet Muhammad and not the contrary. This research aims to prove that the prophet Muhammad would never have preached nor taught anything that contradicts the Quran, and this would automatically exonerate him from all such fabricated hadith.

It is not possible to detail all the contradictory hadith as their number is immense, so the following are a good selection of these glaring contradictions, and for convenience purpose, they have been placed in groups.

Part 1
Part 2
Part 3

Original Link: http://www.quran-islam.org/articles/hadith_not_from_prophet_%28P1177%29.html

12 thoughts on “Prophet Muhammad is innocent from the Hadiths”

  1. This is suggestion.
    Part of the disbelieving-cynical critic image that come across me as I read through this site would be saying… Who are you to claim the words above this all? Does it make you so proud to be angry of what has taken place? Does your vision encompass through the time enough to call something wrong or Satanic?…
    You would have a better credibility if you put forth all the contradicting verses from both Quran and hadith without inserting your personal views on it. In all the way, personality is biased and always prone to deception. Quran is indeed not written by man. Hadiths are. Why should we be interested in your narration when you put higher ratio of personal commentaries rather than referring to which are real?
    Sorry if you are hurt. But take this advice and prioritize only actual references on articles.

    Like

    1. This is not the only article about the hadiths, I have 2 other bigger articles which provides all the details of these texts.

      I am not seeking for my own truth, but just the naked crude truth. and for me the truth is that the hadiths have not their place in the religion, they are not Muhammad’s sayings, they are not a completion of the religion, they are a mix of truths and lies forged by Iblis and those who have a sickness in their hearts.

      I am not forcing anyone to follow my beliefs, I’ve just presented my proofs and up to each one to believe whatever he wants.

      So I am not hurt by your claims, you have your own beliefs, you can even worship a stone and say it’s God, or write your own religious book, that’s your problem not mine.

      Have a good day

      Like

      1. Thanks. I’m glad you’re self convinced enough. I do believe the truest and the only purest correct Islam is only the one the prophet practiced long ago. Now everything is spread over and mixed up. I do have biased too as a person, mainly due to emotional nature as a woman, hence I need a lot of adjustments. And adjustment isn’t correct when it only comes from another bias. I hope you understand as I do understand your expressions here, just that as a reader, I would demand more. Sorry. And Thank you.

        – Allah te bendiga –

        Like

      2. The Quran is complete and contains all the details, Allah has sent it to each one of us and has commanded us to obey it DIRECTLY, it’s the simple way of Allah. The prophet Muhammad applied the Quran FOR HIS TIME, but the Quran applies for all times and all places and its interpretation is proper to each person, we cannot take a past context and use it for own present context which is very very different from Muhammad’s time. That is if we suppose that the hadiths are true, which as I have showed it does not seem to be the case.

        If you read the Quran without using any islamic interpretation but relying on your own understanding, you would see how different is the religion defined in the Quran compared to what is islam is today.

        The prophet does not have his own teachings in completion to the Quran, the prophet only applied it on himself in his context in his time, each one has to do the same than the prophet, which means to apply the Quran in his own context and time and for his own personal case.

        I only want the people to follow the truth and to have their own guidance and path from Allah, and not to be mere followers without discernment, but only to follow Allah’s direct guidance. Allah is alive and is ruling right now the world, Allah guides each one of us if we turn to Him alone and stop taking intermediaries. How the people want Allah to guide them if they keep following other people instead of Allah directly?

        I am not intending to hurt you or to criticize you, but just to clarify my point.

        Like

  2. Thank you for all your, this article and this website is a fresh and honest gift to people who want to follow in the way of Allah. I agree with you that the Quran is the only source we as Muslims should focus on and apply it to our current time and lives. The Hadiths although can provide some insight into the life of the Messenger (SAWS), as you pointed out he did not want anyone to write his way of life down and only said to follow the Holy Quran. I believe that if more Muslims understood this then it would be much better. Again thank you for all you do and Glod Bless!

    Like

    1. thank you ….. believe me most of the hadiths are only the work of Ibliss and are to deviate the believers on a false path. Allah has sent the Quran and only commands us to follow his revelation and not any other text. The whole instructions that Allah gave to Muhammad are the in the Quran, if there were any further command, it would be in the Quran.

      Like

  3. Hello brother,

    What you are doing on your Youtube and this website is a breath of fresh air; absolutely amazing. I have been seeking the truth most of my life even tho I am born a muslim humdullah I was obeying blindly. I have went through my own experiences in life that have shown the evils and lies of this world and if I didn’t keep searching even after the devil was misguiding me through every trail I would of believed and practiced the wrong things for sure. I really had to push through and keep asking Allah for guidness and search for myself. I am so thankful I am here now and see the world through different eyes.

    I do definitely agree with you about the hadiths but i do have some questions. In the Quran does it specifically say stay away from hadith and does it say anywhere to only accept true hadith.

    Also I want to practice Only through the Quran but I am afraid if I leave some hadiths Allah will be angry at me. You might have wrote about this question maybe but i have just discovered your website so
    I will read up more inshAllah, but hopefully you can answer some of my questions I will list below.

    Do woman have to cover hair in Islam or just dress modestly?

    Ive seen somewhere you wrote about Quran says pray only 3 times? Can you please elaborate.

    What about gusl/ablution— since many women also ask about wetting of the hair completely every time they perform gusl.. and if it is mandatory or not.

    Thank you for all your GREAT work I really do appreciate you and support you, I also started my own outlets for people to learn truth.. I am even taking some of your work and showing people the truth.

    May Allah guide you more and bless you…

    Like

    1. hello brother,
      thank you, I am trying to spread the truth of God to the people, the truth of the Quran.

      The true believer is the one who recognizes the truth when he meets it and who adapts his beliefs when the proofs are presented to him. Allah has indeed guided you to his real path, the path of the Quran.

      The Quran never says to follow any other book …. and when the Quran mentions the hadiths, it only mentions them as a huge perdition, the false wisdom of Iblis.

      The Quran contains all the least details of what we need to know in order to obey God and to do what is good and to avoid what is bad.

      You obey God when you leave the hadiths , because the hadiths are not the law of God and are not what the prophet Muhammad said. The prophet Muhammad did not have his own law beside the Quran, the sole and only law is the law of the Quran.When you’ll learn enought about the Quran, you will be able to see that everyting is said in the Quran and that the hadiths actually say the contrary of the Quran.The hadiths are the pure work of Iblis, and are 100% perdition.

      The women do not have to cover their hair but to dress and to act decently.

      Actually, the Quran mentions 2 salats, and indeed there are only 2 mandatory salats. These salats are not related to the sun but to our daily activity, salat Al Fjar when you wake up, and a salat Al Icha when you end your day, salat means connexion, Allah wants us to connect with him before to start our activities and when we have finised our duties, that way, we stay connected to Allah during the whole day. The Salat is far more freee than the muslim Salat. The Salat as definied in the Quran consist in connecting to Allah, which means to dedicate a specific time, you alone and Allah, and during the salat you can mention him in your head and with your loud voice, you can mention him in any position that you want, it is free and it depends on you.

      Ablution is indeed mandatory before Salat, Allah does not command us to put water on our head and foot, but only to pass our hands on them, after having washed our hands and faces with water.

      I am working on articles about the true Salat, true Hajj, true Ramadan, True zakat, and many other practices .. because the muslim way is not the one of the Quran. I’ve recently discovered that even some of the articles of my website are not accurate enought concerning the Salat, the Haj, the Ramadan etc etc, I’ve found these contents on other websitse years ago as they were closer to the truth than the islamic way, I’ve kept the, and spread them, but now that Allah has showed me a new knoweldge, I am able to know how to make these practices exactly like the quran says it, without any trick, just what the Quran says clearly…. and now I am able to see that the true way of Allah makes sense, is easier, and produce a true result… I’ve tested this new way on mlyself, and I am amazed by the result. I am now more than happy to make my Salat and now ity makes sense to me, weheras before, I felt that I was forcing myself and that my old way was mechanical and not adapted and natural.

      Like

      1. SubhanAllah,

        I just thought of something right now, could it be that Satan has devised a very very clever plan to twist the real prayers of the Quran to make it obligatory to mankind and thus make it hard for the people to keep up with the 5 daily prayers and it’s mechanical ways and leave it all together? I have searched the internet for ” Shytan has manipulated true Quran Prayers” and have found nothing. Maybe you could elaborate on this for people on YouTube and on your website inshAllah. Because I too have found praying the 5 daily prayers with the way I have learned made me feel mechanical at times and pushed me to delay it. Some people leave it all together because it feels like a burden to them, if they don’t complete all 5 prayers they feel what is the use and completely stop praying. Even the hadiths which say that women can not wear nail polish when they pray have turned off many many muslim women from prayer. But does the Quran even talk about taking off nail polish off the finger nails in order for prayer to suffice? If you address this and make it public through your outlets it will most definitly guide a vast majority of muslim females and guide them to prayer.

        Also a side question, Is it punishable if we do not wake up for fajr prayer at the exact time and delay it ? because this too is a huge problem for most muslims to do. So when they miss fair prayer they are turned away from even completing any other prayers that day.

        Also the Night journey that Muhammad (SAW) took and Allah revealed the 5 daily prayers, was that even truth from the Quran? This addresses a new topic most people should be aware of.

        I am looking forward to see your upcoming work and let me know if there is anything you might need help with to further expand this if need be; nevertheless I have been sharing most of your work.

        Thank you again,

        Allah is Great

        Like

      2. Iblis has 2 ways to deceive: to command us to do less, or to command us to do more than Allah asks.

        Concerning the Salat, it is obvious that Allah never asked us to make so many salats and with this way. When you see that the muslims say that there are 5 Salats + many many optional Salats … This extreme rythm aims to make us do mechanical salats which are a burden for us without any benefit. Even the form of the Salat is made to make us become mechanical: the same gestures, the high number of rakaa and postures, the same words during the salat which are absolutely not adapted to our current needs and which are not personal …. all of this makes the Salat becomes the opposite of its natural form and goal.

        The story about the night journey is a complete fabrication, Allah never showed to Muhammad how to make salat during this journey because the salat was already very well described in the Quran. All what we need to know is in the Quran, Allah will not send to us more than 600 pages of quran and forget at the same time to give us the details of his pillars… this does not make sense…and Allah makes sense. Of course the muslims will never find their way of Salat, Hajj, Ramadan, … etc in the Quran, because their way is a complete forgery. The way of Allah for these practices is far easier and logic and is adapted to anyone on earth, and benefits us and do not harm us, that’s my true Allah…. and not the one of the practices of false islam

        There are 2 mandatory daily Salats, one in the morning, the other in the evening, to start our day and to end it, these 2 Salats are not to be made during the rising of the sun and its setting, but when we wake up and before to sleep, these 2 Salats are meants to keep us connected to Allah all the day. The real Salat Fajr as described in the Quran is not to be done when the sun rises or when we see the first ray of line of light, but when you wake up, and this depends on each one’s job, habits, etc ….

        Do you think that Allah does not know that we work everyday and that our work does not depend on the sun but on the hour of the day (8am to 5pm generally). With Fajr either you wake up in the middle of the night, when your sleep is the deepest, or it is not long before we normally wake upr before to go to work … so you cannot sleep after it …. With this version of Fajr, either you focus in your salat Fajr and you cannot sleep after, either you deliberatly remain a bit asleeped in order to sleep easier after the salat, but in this case, you are not focused during your salat. There is no solution with the old way of Salat.

        The true salat is to be done when we are fully waken up and focused and that we are about to start our day activity. The Salat which means connexion is a kind of communion with God, a moment fully dedicated to Allah, and this is possible only when we are in our privacy at home … which confirms the non existence of the other Salats (which are supposed to be done when we are at work). However Allah says that there is only one salat at the middle of the day and it is only once a week, the friday collective Salat, it is the only one which is in the middle of the day, which is logic, it is collective, it is when the people are all out and not at their homes. The daily Salat is in private and the collective salat is collective…logic.

        Allah also says that we can do as many optional salats as we want, and Allah mentions some key moments in the day like the sunrise; sunset, in the middle of the night ….. Allah does not ask us to wake in the middle of the night to pray…it depends of our schedule and our activity, sometimes we are waken up durting the night for a specific reason … etc etc and with Allah’s new form of Salat, there is not need to have special conditions,; Salat is easier and can even be done just in your head.

        So don’t worry about your fajr, now you can do your Salat when you wake up and you can make it without fear that you are late.

        Before when I used to do 5 salats, I missed many of them and I grouped many of them, and I was able to do them in 1 minute, it was not honnest, it was not natural … I was far more focused on Allah outside the salat rather during the salat itself…for me it is a sign that this old way of Salat is not adapted and is the way of Iblis.

        Since I’ve switched to the new way of Salat, I take far far more time to do it and I do not feel bored or in a hurry, because I can schedule at the beginning of my day and at the end of my day a time to make the Salat without being in a hurry, and because during my Salat, now I speak with Allah, it’s an interactive live Salat …whereas before it was a fixed Salat with fixed words …. which is very boring for Allah and for us and does not produce any result as it cannot be sincere, we are supposed to adapt our prayers with our faith and with our needs. No one on earth can now say that he has no time for the salat as it is at the beginning of our day and at the end of our day. since I’ve swtiched to the method of the Quran for the salat, I am far more focused and above all I feel that I am with Allah during the whole day…. the result are 100% here.

        Concenring the nail polish and other details … all of this has been invented by the devil in order to make everything complicated and in order to push the people into hypocrisy. Iblis likes to give us false excuses in order to give us false reasons no to make the salat.

        Allah judges us according to our beliefs, so Allah judges the muslims according to their false beliefs of the hadiths etc …. and many of them do not even obey to their false beliefs, they are not sincere, they are not logic with themselves, they say in public that they are happy with their version of islam, but in their head, they are bothered and do many of their religious practices without any true intent, without any pleasure or sincerity … they complain in their head that these practices are too hard (which is true) …. and when Allah shows them the true method, a method which solve all their problems at the same time… they prefer to stay with their old way… This is because they are not sincere, they do not really care…. about anything except themselves.

        Thanks for sharing my work, you are just sharing the truth and not my own work, you are doing what Allah commands us to do.

        It is good to see people who still think and who put all their efforts to find the truth, you’ve been rewarded, because now Allah has revealed to you what is truly commanded to us in the Quran.

        When Allah gives us a simple instructions, and allows us to adapt our practices depending on our personnality, on the context etc etc … Iblis gives One way, a very complicated way, impossible to be done at the perfection, not adapted to anyone earth, and which produces the exact opposite of what the true commands of Alah are supposed to produce.

        Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s